01 October 2006

1062) Australian Newspaper Insults Ataturk

An Australian newspaper published a cartoon showing Australian Finance Minister Peter Costello pulling Ataturk’s body from his grave.

In the cartoon, Ataturk was holding a paper that read “Armenian genocide.”

A caption under the cartoon read, “He [Castello] raiseth up Ataturk.”
. . In the article accompanying the cartoon, the writer asserted Turkey abolished most of the restrictions imposed by Ataturk.

Dennis Altman, writer of the article, indicated it was ironic of Costello to have praised Turkey last week.

The article claimed Ataturk saw religion as a barrier against progress; therefore, he attempted to prevent religion from holding a public role in modern Turkey.

It was further asserted that Ataturk tried to impose his opinions in a way that could shock both secular and pious Australians.

During a speech last week, Costello pointed to secular Turkey, founded by Ataturk, who commanded Turkish forces in Gallipoli, as a model of leadership for the Islamic world.

By Anka, Sidney
October 01, 2006

Contact Details for the Newspaper:
Address : The Age Company Ltd, 250 Spencer Street, Melbourne, Victoria. 3000. Australia.(ABN : 85 004 262 702)
Postal address : PO Box 257C, Melbourne, VIC 8001, Australia
Editorial newsdesk : (03) 9601 2250
Editorial newsdesk (fax) : (03) 9601 2332
Editorial e-mail : newsdesk@theage.com.au
Reader feedback : (03) 9604 1136
Contact The Age Online: http://www.theage.com.au/contact.html

From: Yuksel Oktay
Subject: People's Forum Letter by Melissa Papantones Published on Sept 24, 2006
To: Editorial@thewesterlysun.com

30 September 2006

Dear Editor,

The letter of Melissa Papantones, published in the Western Sun’s People’s Forum (Sunday Sept. 24, 2006), shows the ignorance of not only the writer but also of the newspaper which should have done a little resaearch on Ataturk before allowing it to be published. The letter is typical of individuals with Greek and Armenian heritage around the world and some misguided Turks, who write with vengeance, always resorting to lies and distorted facts in order to deceive the readers.

Mustafa Kemal Ataturk was one of the greatest leaders of the twentieth century who defeated the Greek armies who invaded western Anotolia on May 15, 1919 following the World war I with the support of the western powers. Mr. Venizelos, the Greek Prime Minister and one of the architects of the ‘’Greek Tragedy’’, was among the losers, but admitting the righteousness of the great humantiarian, he did not hesitate to nominate Mustafa Kemal Ataturk for the Nobel Peace Prize.

There was no genocide of the Greeks, the Armenians or any other people, as the writer states, but the massacre of Ottoman Turks by the Armenians who wanted to create a nation of their own on lands where they were not the majority, led to a civil war during the catastrophic World War I. This forced the Ottoman Government rightfully to the re-location of Armenians in 1915 to other parts of the empire and away from the war zones with the consequential death of many Armenians and the population exchange between Turkey and Greece in 1924 through a teraty prevented more deaths.

On September 22, 2006, the Minister of Treasury of Australia Peter Costello, praised Ataturk as a role model for leadership. Below is a commentary on Mustafa Kemal Ataturk’s leadership and contribution to humanity whose motto was ‘’Peace at Home, Peace in the World’’, which was written in 2003, if you care to publish in your newspaper. If the newspaper would like to give its readers an opportunity to learn about Ataturk, perhaps the review of three books on Ataturk and Turkey that was sent to the US secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld could also be published.


Yuksel Oktay P:E:,
Istanbul, Turkey


Last year, the New York Times reported that Prof. Dr. Arnold M. Ludwig of University of Kentucky placed Ataturk first in his list of 377 leaders of the world who changed the fate of their countries and the world. Reading books on the leaders of the 20th century from Rosewelt to Hitler, from Saddam to Bush, one can easily conclude that Ataturk comes out as the towering figure most devoted to his country and to his people and changed the course of history.

In his book ''On Leadership'', John W. Gardner lists fourteen attributes for effective leadership, including physical vitality and stamina, intelligence, willingness to accept responsibilities and, probably the most important one, adaptability and flexibility of approach. For the last attribute, Mr. Gardner presents Kemal Ataturk as the model and states:

''It was said of Kemal Ataturk, the greatest figure in modern Turkish history, that he could shift swiftly and without second thought from a failing tactic to another approach, and if that did not work, to still another. Whether the fields of action was war or diplomacy or domestic governance, he rarely clung to an approach that was not producing results. His goals were stable but his tactics flexible.''

In the same book, Mr. Gardner again gives the example of Kemal Ataturk for renewing a nation and writing history and states:

''In some systems that have gone too long without renewal, people understand that change is needed and restless. This was spectacularly true of Turkey when Kemal Ataturk, one of the great renewers of modern times, was a young officer. Long before World War I he had joined the Young Turks who sought a constitutional government for the decaying 600 year old Ottoman Empire. After the war, he drove out the various foreign powers threatening Turkey's autonomy, created the Turkish republic, and then as President, launched an extraordinary series of reforms. He dis-established Islam as the state religion; abolished old codes subordinating women; substituted the Roman alphabet for the Arabic; instituted a new civil and penal code; abolished the traditional, mainly religious educational system, and established secular states''.

In Newsweek’s latest issue, George Will has told the Californians that they need someone like Ataturk to solve their budget problems who was probably the only leader in Turkey’s history with a balanced budget. Not long ago, House Speaker Newt Gingrich had made a similiar comment to the members of the US Congress to put their educational problems in order, just like Ataturk did after establishing the Republic of Turkey. The Governor of South Carolina, HE Mark Stanford in the US and others like him also made similiar comments, praising Ataturk. The legendary publisher of Times Henry Luce knew the greatness of Mustafa Kemal Pasa and put his picture on the cover of its 3rd issue on March 24, 1923. From Nehru to Enver Sedat, many world leaders wrote in their memoirs that they were inspired by ATATURK in the reforms that they started in their own countries.

Ataturk wanted everyone living in Turkey to be a citizen of Turkey and made sure they had last names. Ataturk traveled around his beloved country extensively, even visiting Tunceli in 1937 for the opening of a bridge, despite being the center of a Kurdish revolt started by the instigations of the British. Lord Kinross wrote his famous biography of Ataturk and Andrew Mango presented Ataturk in every aspect in his book. Probably no other leader has been written about as much as Ataturk and many libraries in the US have some of the books. President Clinton in his opening statement at the Turkish Parliament in November of 1999 stated, ‘’We are here today because of Ataturk’’. Clinton knew who Ataturk was and what he had done for Turkey and the world.

Than there are the enemies of Ataturk and Turkey who will tell you all kinds of stories and invent mythical claims against a man adored by millions. The sad Armenian issue took place long before he came to power and those who do not know the truth twist the facts of history. But what is most saddening is the efforts of some people, including those pretending to be friends of Turkey, to diminish the importance of Ataturk and his role in shaping the 20th century. Even Graham Fuller from the United States, who was not allowed to speak at the Middle East Technical University in Ankara just last week, goes around making statements on Ataturk that misleads the people.

Mustafa Kemal Pasa was a victorious general who won battles against the invaders of his country with the support of his people. As the president of Turkey for 15 years, Ataturk was also a successful statesman who abolished the Sultanatte and declared to the world that the country he created, The Republic of Turkey, will follow his motto ‘’Peace at home Peace in the World’’, not afraid to state that ‘’war not in the defense of one’s country is murder’’.

Ataturk established friendship with all its neighbors by forming the seeds of alliances, from the Balkan Pact to Baghdat Pact, knowing its importance in the economic development of his poor country. These pacts were destroyed in later years for reasons that I don’t know and obstacles were created to block the development of friendship and trade between Turkey and its neighbors. Last year, Turkish government rejected the trip of Syrian president to Turkey for a silly reason, stating that the Syrian maps show Hatay as part of their country, while the former Secretary of State Christopher was visiting Syria continuously, never stopping in Turkey. Turkey is still being discouraged from opening its border gates between Armenia and eastern provinces, demanding that they change their constitution first and delete a statement on the so called Armenian genocide that no one in his right mind believes anyway. This is what Ataturk stated on the Armenian issue during his ynaugural speech of the 3rd Year of Session of the TGNA in 1922:

‘’The Armenian issue, which aims at meeting the economic interests of the capyitalist worl rayther than bearing in mind the veritable interests of the Armenians themselves, was best resolved with the Kars agreement. The friendly ties between two industrious people coexisting peacefully for centuries have been satisfactorily established anew.

Ataturk saved Turkey from external enemies and created the only democracy in the Middle East which will last forever. Now it is up to us to save Turkey from the enemies of Ataturk, both within the country and around the world, by teaching the principles and the lasting achivements of the greatest leader of the 20th century, MUSTAFA KEMAL ATATURK..

Yuksel Oktay,
Istanbul, 3 July 2003


Post a Comment

Would You Please Update/Correct Any Of The
3500+ Posts by Leaving Your Comments Here
- - - Your Opinion Matters To Us - - -

We Promise To Publish Them Even If We May Not Share The Same View

Mind You,
You Wouldn't Be Allowed Such Freedom In Most Of The Other Sites At All.

You understand that the site content express the author's views, not necessarily those of the site. You also agree that you will not post any material which is false, hateful, threatening, invasive of a person’s privacy, or in violation of any law.

Please read the post then write a comment in English by referring to the specific points in the post and do preview your comment for proper grammar /spelling.

Note To Spammers
If you believe Your Comments will ever appear here, You are DREAMING

You need a Google Account (such as Gmail) to publish your comments

Publishing Your Comments Here:
Please type your comment in plain text only (NO Formatting) in an editor like notepad first,
Then copy and paste the final/corrected version into the comment box here as Google/Blogger may not allow re-editing/correcting once entered in some cases.
And click publish.
-If you need to correct the one you have already sent, please enter "New Comment" as we keep the latest version and delete the older version as default

Alternative way to send your formatted comments/articles:

All the best